The passcodes used by smartphone owners to access their devices have been given significant legal protection in the US.
A court in Pennsylvania ruled that the codes are protected by the Fifth Amendment, which defends against self-incrimination, meaning that law enforcement agencies can no longer demand suspects hand over the passwords to their devices.
However, the ruling did not extend to fingerprint access, which was deemed to be similar to having your prints taken at a police station.
The Register reported that the pair were accused of running an insider-trading scam whilst employed at the bank which ultimately netted $2.8m of investments from just a $150,000 initial stake, reportedly thanks to using Capital One’s internal records to make stock market bets on as many as 170 companies.
The two former analysts were given with smartphones by Capital One, but the company let them pick the passcodes themselves to maintain security.
When the two were fired in January 2015 they handed back the mobiles, which the SEC now wants to access to check for evidence – however the Pennsylvania court ruled that forcing the pair to unlock the passcode-protected devices would violate their constitutional rights as laid out by the Fifth Amendment.
“Absent waiver of the confidentiality attendant to this personal thought process, we cannot find the personal passcodes to the Bank’s smartphones to be corporate records falling under the collective entity cases. We find Defendants’ confidential passcodes are personal in nature and Defendants may properly invoke the Fifth Amendment privilege to avoid production of the passcodes.”
Kearney also noted that the SEC hadn’t actually proven that the smartphones in question held documents pursuant to the case, and that since the SEC cannot prove that incriminating documents are on the handsets, the agency can’t force defendants to hand over their codes.
What do you know about Internet security? Find out with our quiz!
Thoma Bravo agrees to acquire Darktrace for $5.32 billion in cash, delivering some welcome news…
Customer adoption of AI services embedded in cloud services continues to deliver results for Microsoft,…
TikTok's 'secret source' algorithm is so core to ByteDance, it would rather shut down US…
After relocating from California to Texas in 2020, Oracle's Larry Ellison now reveals plan to…
Share price hit after Meta admits heavy AI spending plans, after posting strong first quarter…
For third time Google delays phase-out of third-party Chrome cookies after pushback from industry and…