Social networking websites will not be required to install filters to prevent illegal file-sharing, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled.
In the case of Sabam versus Netlog, the court found that forcing websites like Facebook to police their users’ activities would breach the right to protection of personal data and the freedom to receive or impart information.
Sabam, a Belgian music rights management company similar to the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), took Netlog, an online social networking platform, to court in 2009 for allowing its users to share music and video clips on its website.
The case was referred to the ECJ, which found that to block illegal file-sharing, Netlog first had to monitor all of the communications between all of its users. This could be potentially harmful to the freedom of information. Since the costly filtering operation would be conducted at Netlog’s expense, it would also impair the company’s right to conduct business.
Last year, Sabam lost a similar case against Belgian ISP Scarlet Extended SA.
“The European Court appears to have ruled out the idea that operators of social network sites and ISPs can be forced – at their own expense – to impose blanket monitoring and filtering aimed at stopping infringements,” commented Michael Gardner, head of the Intellectual Property practice at law firm Wedlake Bell. “The ruling doesn’t stop rights owners seeking more-limited injunctions against social networking sites or ISPs, but they will have to be more ‘proportionate’ in scope and effect.”
German foreign minister warns Russia will face consequences for “absolutely intolerable” cyberattack on ruling party,…
Google is reportedly laying off at least 200 staff from its “Core” organisation, including key…
Investor appeasement? Apple unveils huge $110 billion share buyback program, as sales of iPhone decline…
Tesla retreats from pioneering gigacasting manufacturing process, amid cost cutting and challenges at EV giant
No skynet please. After the US, UK and France pledge human only control of nuclear…
Microsoft's AI investments continue in south east Asia, after investments in Japan, Malaysia, Indonesia, as…
View Comments
I bet Kim DotCom wishes he set up in Europe now. ;-)