Apple Bans Wi-Fi Stumbling Apps

In a continuation of Apple’s controversial method of managing its App Store for the iPhone, the company decided to remove a variety of applications designed to find WiFi hotspots the device can connect to.

These “stumbling” apps run on a private application programming interface (API), which Apple has been known to reject in the past. Technology news site Softpedia reported the removal of WiFi stumbling apps after a developer contacted the site.

The developer of the WiFi-Where, iFiFoFum and yFy applications have had their products removed from the App Store, according to Softpedia. “It also appears that all other competing WiFi enabled apps have been removed as well,” the unnamed developer of WiFi-Where, who goes by the moniker “codemonkey57”, wrote in a blog post. “This is very unfortunate as the past 2-3 months have seen a handful of new WiFi apps get approved. Hopefully Apple will allow this functionality in a future SDK.”

The reports come on the heels of Apple’s decision to remove a slew of applications featuring potentially offensive or suggestive adult content. However, it has been rumored that Apple is considering an “Explicit” tab on the app store that would be limited to adults. According to Cult of Mac, which quoted an unnamed developer in a 24 Feb. posting, Apple introduced “Explicit” as a possible primary category for application submissions in its iTunes Connect system. That category has since disappeared, raising questions about whether Apple was testing the interface or decided to pull back after the news leaked.

In the case of the adult content apps, Apple spokesperson Trudy Muller told Apple blog Macworld that as a policy the company reviews customer complaints about objectionable content. “If we find these apps contain inappropriate material we remove them and request the developer make any necessary changes in order to be distributed by Apple,” she said.

Apple has charted an impressive path to growth with its App Store; research firm IDC recently predicted the number of apps would grow to 300,000 by the end of 2011. With that growth, though, the company has courted controversy with its attempts to craft a fair culture of content regulation. In April 2009, Apple pulled a “Baby Shaker” app, which let users shake their iPhone in order to presumably kill a virtual infant, after protests from a number of groups. It followed that in May by yanking “Me So Holy,” which had attracted protests for its perceived religious insensitivity.

In addition to pulling apps in response to protests, Apple also began taking down programs by developers who allegedly posted false positive reviews, as it did in December when it removed 1,000 applications by Molinker. Apple’s stringency may increase as third-party developers begin creating programs for the company’s upcoming iPad tablet PC, which utilises the new iPhone SDK 3.2 beta.


Nathan Eddy

Nathan Eddy is a contributor to eWeek and TechWeekEurope, covering cloud and BYOD

View Comments

  • At the Wireless Geographic Logging Engine ( http://wigle.net ), a database and mapping system for "Net Stumbling" or "War Driving" hobbyists, we've seen the iPhone provide a low barrier-to-entry for this hobby. It combines a GPS with a Wifi radio, but it can only work when apps like Wifi-Where, WiFiFoFum and others are allowed to exist.

    These apps were inspected for months before finally getting through the nebulous App Store approval process. Some have been available for months or even years. Now, arbitrarily, they are banned. If they use API calls that Apple didn't want them to, why were they approved? Why weren't the developers contacted behind the scenes to address any fiddly technical issues Apple might foresee?

    As users all we see is a useful app, that was paid for, that now can not be updated. We can't find the least used frequency channels to set our access points to, can't take surveys of campus wireless coverage or find rogue wifi on a corporate network. And we can't help with wireless mapping projects. There's no app for that.

  • I wasn't aware that Apple was so religious. I'm an owner of an iPhone, and in the US, so I'm restricted to AT&t, which sucks, but I must say that I'm seriously considering not renewing my contract. I'm an adult, if I want to see adult themed, or explicit apps, I should be able to. If I don't, then I won't download them. As for kids having access, perhaps it's time for fat ass mom to get off the couch, and do some parenting. Don't dumb things down for the rest of us, because someone's too ignorant to learn how to use a feature, that would block their children's access. Furthermore, I get so bored sometimes, it's nice to add "color" to things, and check out something that you don't see everyday. The religious zealots need to realize, also, they don't have to look at the app, either. Not everyone cares about that crap, like they do. AAAAhhhhh!

Recent Posts

TikTok Viewed As Chinese Influence Tool By Most Americans – Poll

Most people in the United States view TikTok as a Chinese influence tool a poll…

10 hours ago

Ofcom Confirms OnlyFans Investigation Over Age Verification

UK regulator confirms it is investigating whether OnlyFans is doing enough to prevent children accessing…

11 hours ago

Ex Google Staff Fired Over Israel Protest File NLRB Complaint

Dismissed staff file complaint with a US labor board, and allege Google unlawfully terminated their…

12 hours ago

Tesla Axes Entire Supercharger Team, Plus Senior Executives

Elon Musk dismisses two senior Tesla executives, plus the entire division that runs Tesla's Supercharger…

13 hours ago

Microsoft, OpenAI Sued By More Newspaper Publishers

Eight newspaper publishers in the US allege Microsoft and OpenAI used their millions of their…

15 hours ago

Binance’s Changpeng Zhao Sentenced To Four Months In Prison

US judge sentences Binance founder, Changpeng Zhao, to four months in prison for ignoring money…

18 hours ago