Twitter Users Protest Footballer’s Disclosure Order

Thousands of Twitter users have tweeted the name of a footballer, in protest at his efforts to force disclosure of a tweeter who first revealed his name, which cannot be used in mainstream media because of an injunction.

Although it has been assumed that privacy orders to not apply to online social media, the footballer has gained a disclosure order that demands Twitter reveal details of the user who posted a list of celebrities with alleged injunctions two weeks ago.  Meanwhile, foreign media such as Forbes have identified the footballer, as has the Scottish Sunday Herald, arguing that the injunction does not apply in Scotland. And the Telegraph has reported that a Times journalist faces a charge of being in contempt of court, for tweeting the footballer’s name.

Naming on Twitter

The row is stressing the UK’s system of injunctions, which exists to protect privacy of people in the media’s eye. Since the Twitter user revealed a (partly incorrect)  list of injunctions, interest has massively increased, and the case has become more widely known, but the mainstream media are unable to repeat information that has now been  tweeted by upwards of 30,000 people – although they can report false rumours which are not subject to an injunction.

“Websites such as Twitter have put a huge strain on the ability of the courts to enforce gagging orders and it has been widely assumed there is no legal redress against them,” said  the BBC‘s media correspondent Torin Douglas. “Now it seems the law is about to be tested.”

The case is about more than just celebrity affairs. Two years ago, Wikipedia and Twitter users broke a super-injunction issued to shipping company Trafigura, which forbade discussion of allegations the company had dumped toxic waste in Cote d’Ivoire – and even banned mention of the injunction.

And while the celebrity Twitter storm has continued, an injunction has been applied to Twitter and Facebook – despite the widespread belief that such a thing cannot be done. The case should have more public sympathy as it is designed to protect a mother and her brain-damaged daughter.

The Attorney General Dominic Grieve has told the BBC he is not seeking contempt proceedings against the Sunday Herald.

Peter Judge

Peter Judge has been involved with tech B2B publishing in the UK for many years, working at Ziff-Davis, ZDNet, IDG and Reed. His main interests are networking security, mobility and cloud

View Comments

  • People who seek to prevent publication of their wrong-doings deserve everything they get.

    Celebrities are entitled to privacy, but if they don't want their extra-marital affairs discussed in public, then don't do it! Let's face it: a Big Brother contestant is an attention seeker, so keeping a secret of this nature may not be a priority.

    As for the concept of stopping people saying they've been prevented from doing something... Come on!

    Injunctions have their place, but it's not for covering up an affair.

    Welcome to over-legislative Britain.

Recent Posts

Dutch PM Raises Cyber Espionage Case With China’s Xi

Beijing visit sees Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte discuss cyber espionage incident with Chinese President…

9 mins ago

Vodafone Germany Confirms 2,000 Job Losses, Amid European Restructuring

More downsizing at Vodafone after German operation announces 2,000 jobs will be axed, as automation…

16 hours ago

AI Poses ‘Jobs Apocalypse’, Warns Report

IPPR report warns AI could remove almost 8 million jobs in the United Kingdom, with…

17 hours ago

Europe’s Longest Hyperloop Test Track Opens

European Hyperloop Center in the Netherlands seeks to advance futuristic transport technology, despite US setbacks

18 hours ago

NHS Scotland Confirms Clinical Data Published By Ransomware Gang

NHS Dumfries and Galloway condemns ransomware gang for publishing patients clinical data after cyberattack earlier…

20 hours ago

Fewer People Using Twitter After Musk Takeover – Report

Research data suggests fewer people are using Elon Musk's X, but platform insists 250 million…

22 hours ago