HP’s headaches continue after it faces a fresh Autonomy lawsuit, and is accused of knowing it was a bad deal
Executives at Hewlett-Packard allegedly ignored warnings before it bought British software maker Autonomy for $11.3 billion (£7.3bn) that the company’s financial numbers had been exaggerated.
HP was also accused of trying to get out of the deal before it closed, according to a new $1 billion (£647m) lawsuit filed by HP shareholders last week.
This new lawsuit, filed 3 May in US District Court in San Francisco, accuses current and former HP executives of failing to do the needed due diligence ahead of the deal for a company that the shareholders called “a polluted and vastly overvalued asset.”
The result of the alleged negligence by the executives and directors was the $8.8 billion (£5.7bn) write-down on the deal HP announced in November 2012 due to what HP officials said were accounting irregularities by Autonomy executives in the months leading up to the deal. According to the lawsuit, the resulting drop in HP’s stock price effectively wiped billions of dollars from the company’s market value.
The lawsuit also claims that HP, desperate to get in on the burgeoning big data software market, vastly overpaid for Autonomy software that was “an outdated product that was not user-friendly.”
Among those named as defendants are CEO Meg Whitman (who was on the company’s board of directors before taking the top job), former CEO Leo Apotheker, former board Chairman Ray Lane (who resigned as chairman last month but remains on the board) and Mike Lynch (who was Autonomy’s founder and CEO at the time of the deal). Lynch has disputed HP’s accusations that he or any other Autonomy executives doctored financial records before the deal, and has said it was HP’s mishandling of the British company afterward that created problems.
Other defendants in the lawsuit, filed on behalf of PGGM Vermogensbeheer – a Dutch pension fund – and other shareholders, include Barclays Capital and Perella Weinberg Partners, which HP hired to look into Autonomy’s business.
HP began negotiating the Autonomy deal in 2010, and Apotheker pushed the deal after he took over as part of his efforts to build HP’s enterprise software capabilities. Autonomy’s software enables businesses to search for and retrieve information in databases and other repositories across computer networks. Whitman was on the board of directors at the time the board approved the acquisition, which closed in 2011.
HP’s announcement of the $8.8 billion (£5.7bn) charge shook a company already struggling after several years of executive instability – Whitman was HP’s third CEO in less than two years – the decline of sales in the global PC market and other issues. It also came only a few months after HP announced an $8 billion (£5.2bn) charge in connection with its $13.9 billion (£9bn) acquisition in 2008 of services vendor EDS Systems.