GSMA Slams Euro Call For Ban On Wireless In Schools

The ongoing debate over the supposed dangers posed by mobile phone usage and wireless signals has exploded once again. An influential European committee has called for a ban on mobile phones and Wi-Fi networks in schools – but industry body the GSM Association (GSMA) has denounced the report as an “unbalanced political assessment, not a scientific report.”

The Council of Europe’s Committee on the Environment, Agriculture and Local and Regional Affairs published a report earlier this month on the potential dangers of electromagnetic fields. The report recommended that European governments take precautionary steps to ban mobile phone and Wi-Fi usage in schools.

No evidence equals unkown danger?

The committee – whose vice-chairman is the former Labour Deputy Prime Minister, Lord Prescott – was studying low frequency radiation risk. Whilst the Council of Europe it is not officially connected to the European Union, it does have influence.

The report made its recommendation to reduce mobile and wireless use in schools, despite admitting that there is a lack of clear scientific and clinical proof. However, it said the lack of proof was reason enough to restric use, just in case, comparing  mobile phone raditation to other things whose dangers were once sunknown, such as asbestos, leaded petrol and tobacco.

“Mobile telephony has become commonplace around the world. This wireless technology relies upon an extensive network of fixed antennas, or base stations, relaying information with radio frequency signals. Over 1.4 million base stations exist worldwide and the number is increasing significantly with the introduction of third generation technology,” said the report.

Euro committee recommends school ban

But it is the report’s recommendations to the member states of the Council of Europe that have angered some.

The report says member states should take “all reasonable measures to reduce exposure to electromagnetic fields, especially to radio frequencies from mobile phones, and particularly the exposure to children and young people who seem to be most at risk from head tumours.”

And it is not just talking about mobile phones, but also the use of normal household DECT phones, Wi-Fi, WLAN and WIMAX and includes the use of baby monitors.

The most controversial of the committee recommendations however is to “ban all mobile phones, DECT phones or WiFi or WLAN systems from classrooms and schools.”

Long Campaign

This will be music to the ears of campaigners who have long been convinced of the dangers of low level radiation. Last year a local law was passed in California that stated that all mobile phones sold in San Francisco had to clearly display the levels of radiation they emit.

However the report’s recommendations and conclusions directly contradicts the advice from both the World Health Organisation and the UK’s Department of Health, which says exposure to electromagnetic fields poses little or no risk to human health.

And a study from Imperial College London in June 2010 also found no cancer risk for children born near mobile phone masts.

Another report by the UK’s Mobile Telecommunications and Health Research Programme in 2007 also found no association between mobile phones and adverse health effects. However it now conducting a more detailed study into the long-term effects of mobile phones.

Despite this, the campaign group Powerwatch, which believes there are risks posed from electromagnetic fields, welcomed the draft resolution.

“We applaud the Council of Europe Committee for this Draft Resolution,” said Powerwatch. “It is long past the time when governments all around Europe should have started being more precautionary about these issues. The suggestions here are strong ones. They will meet with great opposition not only from the industry, but also from governments who now receive large annual tax incomes from wireless devices, especially mobile phone use. This has really thrown down a gauntlet. We await with interest to see who takes up the challenge and what they do.”

Political Report

But that drew short shrift from the GSMA, which reacted angrily to the committee’s findings.

“The Committee draft report is an unbalanced political assessment not a scientific report. It ignores the conclusions of the many authoritative reviews who have found that present safety recommendations provide protection for all persons,” said the GSM Association.

“It is disappointing that the draft relies on the BioInitiative report, which has been criticised by the Health Council of the Netherlands for not being ‘objective and balanced’ and the views of the European Environment Agency, which admits that it has no ‘specific expertise in EMF.’

The report will also raise eyebrows in UK schools, where Wi-Fi networks have become a standard part of teaching equipment, and pupils are increasingly working on wirelessly-connected laptops.

Tom Jowitt

Tom Jowitt is a leading British tech freelancer and long standing contributor to Silicon UK. He is also a bit of a Lord of the Rings nut...

View Comments

  • Are they really going to try and argue that the lack of evidence that it is harmful is enough to prove that it is? And the comparison to asbestos and petrol. They smashed two logical fallacies into one. A lawyer will shoot this down in a heartbeat. Please.

  • Well maybe if we took the wireless links off their computers and took their mobile phones of each of said committee of idiots they would loose the abilty to communicate and just fade into obscurity and we would not have to put up with their ramblings any longer . I do wish people like this would put brain into gear before opening hole in face . Maybe we should organise to send each member a lead lined box for them to sit in and hide from all that naughty RF you know electro magnetic radiation just like light from a light bulb one little message to "The Council of Europe’s Committee on the Environment, Agriculture and Local and Regional Affairs" grow up ... Oh and find a name more befitting of bufoons maybe with the words green party excuse center in the name

  • I think we should ban celeriac on the grounds that there is no evidence that it doesn't do any harm (and I don't like it)

  • Schools are about education - mobile phones have no place there.

    Wifi... That's different and does have a place.

    Of course, I'm referring to social and educational issues, not scientific or environmental ones.

    As for the radiation (I use the word advisedly and as a catch-all in this instance), until we have a full and proper investigation into the long-term effects of these devices, this is a debate which will run. And run...

Recent Posts

Nokia CEO Predicts 2030 Arrival For 6G, But Not On Smartphone

Nokia CEO Pekka Lundmark offers his predictions as to arrival of 6G connectivity in this…

4 hours ago

Mark Zuckerberg Sued By DC AG Over Cambridge Analytica Scandal

Four years later, and Washington DC Attorney General decides to sue Mark Zuckerberg personally over…

5 hours ago

Silicon UK In Focus Podcast: The Future of SaaS

How has Saas become an essential component of a successful business? The importance of a…

9 hours ago

Running to the Cloud: Why Enterprise Companies Need a Cloud-based Payroll

As businesses re-examine how they operate in a post-pandemic world, it is increasingly evident that…

10 hours ago