Father Of Internet Says Web Access Is Not A Human Right

Vint Cerf, one of the so-called ‘fathers of the internet’, has dismissed the argument that internet access is a human right.

Cerf, a fellow at the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers and a vice president of Google, told the New York Times that “technology is an enabler of rights, not a right itself.”

Cerfing the Web

Internet access is increasingly seen as a human right and Cerf acknowledges that the role of social networks and the internet during the Arab Spring has proved to be a catalyst for discussion. However Cerf argues that these arguments miss the point

Egyptian authorities blocked access to Twitter in January as anti-government protesters used it to communicate with each other during demonstrations and even went as far to implement an internet blackout in the country in an attempt to stop protests. Even as recently as December, the Syrian government banned the use of iPhones in the country.

“From the streets of Tunis to Tahrir Square and beyond, protests around the world last year were built on the Internet and the many devices that interact with it,” said Cerf. “They could never have happened as they did without the ability that the Internet offers to communicate, organise and publicise everywhere, instantaneously.”

However Cerf says that there is a high bar for something to be considered a human right as it must be something that humans need to lead healthy lives, such as freedom from torture or conscience. He says that it would be a mistake to put technology in this category as it changes over time and it is merely an enabling factor.

Civil Rights Movement

A UN report ruled that the internet had “become an indispensable tool for realising a range of human rights”, a statement which Cerf says shows the UN agrees that the internet is valuable as the means to an end, not an end itself.

However, Cerf acknowledges that there are stronger arbuments for internet access being a civil, not a human right: “They [civil rights] are conferred upon us by law, not intrinsic to us as human beings.” He cites the US notion of ‘universal service’ which requires services such as telephone, electricity and broadband to be made available in even the most remote regions of the country.

“Improving the Internet is just one means, albeit an important one, by which to improve the human condition. It must be done with an appreciation for the civil and human rights that deserve protection — without pretending that access itself is such a right,” he said.

A BBC World Service poll carried out in March 2010 said that 80 percent of people worldwide considered internet access to be a human right rather than a privilege and the UN is increasingly pushing for it to be declared a universal right.

Spain, Estonia and Finland have all made internet access a legal right, while a US group has officially petitioned the US government to amend the constitution and make web access an unalienable right.

Steve McCaskill

Steve McCaskill is editor of TechWeekEurope and ChannelBiz. He joined as a reporter in 2011 and covers all areas of IT, with a particular interest in telecommunications, mobile and networking, along with sports technology.

View Comments

  • What interesting quaint language. The media always uses words like 'father' as though there are some sort of religious people around who are the godfathers and benefactors of us all. Why do you not use words like 'pioneer' or 'architect' or 'developer' because it they have fewer connotations. You see that someone does the original work and if people 'like' the product that is sold to them they then develop it further or keep it and they don't like it they 'can' also ditch it after all it is a fee world isn't it?

Recent Posts

UK’s CMA Begins Probe Of Viasat Acquisition Of Inmarsat

British competition regulator the CMA, begins phase one investigation of $7.3 billion merger between Inmarsat…

8 hours ago

Cisco Admits ‘Security Incident’ After Breach Of Corporate Network

Yanluowang ransomware hackers claim credit for compromise of Cisco's corporate network in May, while Cisco…

10 hours ago

Google Seeks To Shame Apple Over RCS Refusal

Good luck convincing Tim. Google begins publicity campaign to pressure Aple into adopting the cross…

11 hours ago

Elon Musk Wants Staff Names Of Twitter’s Bot Counters

Fight with Twitter, sees Elon Musk's legal team requesting names of those employees who calculate…

12 hours ago

Former Twitter Executive Convicted Of Spying For Saudi Arabia

Spying scandal. Former Twitter executive found guilty in San Francisco courtroom of spying for Saudi…

16 hours ago

Meta Raises $10 Billion In Bond Offering

First ever bond offering sees Facebook parent Meta Platforms raise $10 billion, as it seeks…

17 hours ago