Cloud Is Risky But Safer Than Offshoring, CFOs Say

Chief financial officers may be wary of the risks that cloud computing initiatives hold but they see offshoring their financial processes as being more dangerous.

Research by Ovum found that 29 percent of CFOs in the UK and US viewed cloud as “posing an unacceptable risk” for finance and accounting systems, but 38 percent expressed similarly strong concerns over outsourcing to India. Even more (44 percent) were troubled by the thought of a move to South and Central American countries.

Popular India Is Least Satisfactory

India proved to be an interesting region for financial offshoring. Although it proved to be the most popular country for those who have already taken the plunge, it also rated as the lowest for satisfaction. On a scale of one to four, Asia-Pacific came top (3.78), the UK was down the list at second bottom (3.61), but India was a distant last with only 3.08.

“The fact that India received the lowest satisfaction ratings of any region, and by some distance, indicates there is a very real trade-off in terms of satisfaction versus cost. India is known to produce some of the lowest-priced accounting staff in the world but it would seem that, in many instances, vendors are cutting corners as well as costs,” commented Peter Ryan, Ovum lead analyst.

One of the main obstacles to an offshore move was loyalty felt towards existing staff. This was stated as the case by 44 percent of the CFOs.

“We don’t know if this is due to a sense of responsibility for their staff,” Ryan said, “or a desire to keep their skills – but it is likely to be a combination of the two. Concerns over losing control, which is traditionally seen as the biggest barrier, was pushed into joint second place with the worry that it would not save enough money to be worthwhile (31 percent).”

The CFOs were also sceptical that outsourcing within their own country would prove worthwhile. This was contrasted by the feeling expressed by those who already outsource. This group felt that processes had become more efficient than in-house operations. On a rising scale of satisfaction from one to four, the average rating for outsourced processes was 3.28, compared to 3.22 for in-house operations.

The lure of a 20 percent cost reduction still would not tempt the resistant CFOs to move operations offshore, but the more adventurous outsourcing group could be lured to switch suppliers for a reduction of just 15 percent.

Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz

Eric is a veteran British tech journalist, currently editing ChannelBiz for NetMediaEurope. With expertise in security, the channel, and Britain's startup culture, through his TechBritannia initiative

View Comments

  • Europe has always been backwards at adopting new technology and practices (such as offshoring).

  • Cloud will become a more attractive proposition for companies. The issue isn't whether it is or is not secure. It is the lack of transparency or being able to prove compliance that holds cloud back at the moment. Service providers have a duty to put more focus on compliance and governance and opening their offerings to external scrutiny

Recent Posts

Amazon Pumps Another $2.75 Billion Into Anthropic

Amazon completes its $4bn investment into AI firm Anthropic, after providing an additional $2.75bn in…

36 mins ago

The Sustainability of AI

While AI promises unparalleled efficiency, productivity, and innovation, questions regarding its environmental impact loom large.…

3 hours ago

Trump’s Truth Social Makes Successful Market Debut

Shares in Donald Trump’s social media company rose about 16 percent after first day of…

4 hours ago

Dutch PM Raises Cyber Espionage Case With China’s Xi

Beijing visit sees Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte discuss cyber espionage incident with Chinese President…

4 hours ago

Vodafone Germany Confirms 2,000 Job Losses, Amid European Restructuring

More downsizing at Vodafone after German operation announces 2,000 jobs will be axed, as automation…

21 hours ago

AI Poses ‘Jobs Apocalypse’, Warns Report

IPPR report warns AI could remove almost 8 million jobs in the United Kingdom, with…

22 hours ago