Bill Gates is to testify in court over Novell’s allegation that Microsoft unfairly crushed WordPerfect
The former CEO and co-founder of Microsoft, Bill Gates, is once again to appear in court over a antitrust lawsuit against Redmond, filed by open-source business software-maker Novell.
Novell claims that Microsoft relied on illegal practices to crush WordPerfect, a rival to Microsoft Word.
The long-running suit, originally filed in November 2004, centres on Novell’s claims that Microsoft withheld critical Windows 95 technical information, which in turn made it difficult to deliver a version of WordPerfect that was compatible with that operating system.
For its part, Microsoft has argued that Novell wasn’t an operating system competitor during the mid-1990s, the period under discussion, and that WordPerfect’s market share collapse was solely due to Novell’s corporate mismanagement. Novell eventually sold the WordPerfect line to Corel in 1996, for a fraction of the price it paid to acquire the property in 1994; however, it retained the rights to some of the underlying technology, which it baked into products such as the GroupWise messaging and collaboration platform.
Even as Microsoft and Novell have continued their courtroom battle, the two companies have collaborated in other areas. Late last year, Novell said it would sell some of its intellectual property assets to CPTN Holdings, a consortium of technology companies organised by Microsoft. The actual intellectual property in question was unspecified, although the Microsoft-led consortium was willing to pay some $450 million (£285m) for it; Katherine Egbert of research firm Jefferies & Co. postulated at the time that the assets could relate somehow to WordPerfect.
That deal hit some snags, however, when the US Department of Justice and the Securities and Exchange Commission began to pick over the associated patents. In turn, that interfered with Attachmate’s attempts to acquire Novell for some $2.2 billion (£1.4bn). After a few weeks, federal regulators allowed the deal to go through, and Attachmate Group reported it had completed the acquisition in late April.
Gates has testified in Microsoft’s defence before, most notably during the company’s 1998 antitrust investigation by the federal government. Microsoft eventually settled, agreeing to third-party access to its product source code for a limited period, in addition to other measures.
According to Bloomberg, Gates could face extensive cross-examination by Novell’s representation, with a laser focus on his decision-making process at the time.