The following is an opinion editorial by Erez Dagan of Mobileye and
This press release features multimedia. View the full release here:
Mobileye Executive Vice President Erez Dagan says Responsibility-Sensitive Safety, the same framework that solves the road safety challenge for autonomous vehicles, is also capable of dramatically improving the safety of the road today via advanced driver assistance systems. The solution digitizes the mostly informal, hard-to-enforce “social contract” that governs road safety today. (Credit: Mobileye)
When Mobileye set out to design a safety concept for autonomous vehicles
(AVs), we first had to examine the concepts and mechanisms that humans
use to maintain road safety. We needed a framework fully compliant with
the human road safety system so that AVs could share the same roads. We
also needed something demonstrably safer, by design, for society to
accept them on the roads.
During development of this system, we discovered the same framework that
solves this challenge for AVs is also capable of dramatically improving
the safety of the road today via advanced driver assistance systems
(ADAS). The solution digitizes the mostly informal, hard-to-enforce
social contract that governs road safety today. How this works was the
subject of my keynote address today at SAE World Congress.
The Gap in Our Traffic Rules
The foundation of the existing road safety system is traffic rules:
explicit, unequivocal instructions to the driver, coded through on-road
and road-side signs and indicators such as traffic lights, stop signs,
lane dividers, etc.
Still, traffic rules are an under-defined system. Even if all agents
rigorously follow them there is still a risk of road accidents. This is
because the alternative – to over-define with traffic lights at every
junction (no roundabouts) and by making every lane line always solid –
would be costly and degrade traffic flow to impractical levels.
Dashed lane lines and yield signs allow for more efficiency, but also
leave points of potential conflict in which road users must negotiate
with one another (for example, when changing lanes or at a four-way
stop). Had these negotiations been left completely unregulated, the
outcomes would be a wild function of the different agents’ time-utility
This is where the social contract comes in.
The social contract governing careful driving is meant to compensate for
the safety gap left by the fact that the traffic rules are
under-determined. It minimizes the occurrence of time-critical conflicts
and regulates negotiations between road users by directing agents to
keep a safe distance from the car ahead, to proceed with caution when
visibility is compromised, to give up the right of way if others claim
it, and so on. It is a social contract in the sense that we all uphold
this unspoken set of rules because we are all better off if we do.
The social contract supersedes traffic rules and can therefore remedy
the consequences of traffic rule violations. For example, the social
contract would allow an agent to cross a solid lane line if a vehicle in
the opposite lane has crossed it right in front him (as long as it does
not lead to a different social contract violation).
Despite its critical role in the human road safety system, the social
contract for cautious driving has shortcomings. It is broad, without
specific definitions of what is safe or appropriate, leaving the correct
application up to real-time human judgments. Hence, a lapse of judgment
is a leading cause of accidents. The social contract is also nearly
impossible to enforce, since detecting a violation requires detailed
analysis of a traffic situation.
Digitizing the Social Contract for AVs
Humans must interpret this implicit, non-metric system as they go. But
for AVs – which are necessarily explicit and quantitative in their
decision-making – we need a more accessible interpretation of this
contract. This is the exact premise of Mobileye’s Responsibility-Sensitive
Safety (RSS) framework: a digital interpretation of the social
contract that is explicit, concise, (para)metric, efficiently applicable
in real-time and retrospectively traceable.
RSS has several additional contributions critical to road safety. First,
it is a formally proven contract, meaning that it is mathematically
proven that if all agents implement RSS the vehicle will not cause an
accident resulting from a decision-making process, assuming all other
vehicle-relevant factors function appropriately. Second, by being
completely explicit and quantitative, it aids investigators after an
accident regarding different agents’ compliance with the digital social
From Humans to AVs and Back
What started with the AV’s duty to comprehend the human road safety
system evolved into an undeniable opportunity to dramatically improve it.
With a safety model that is fully measurable, interpretable and
enforceable, we wondered: Why wait for AVs to experience the life-saving
benefits of this new reality? Let’s find a way to allow human drivers to
benefit from RSS – the digital version of the social contract.
To that aim, we have designed the Vision
Zero driver-assistance system, which is purpose-built to meet
mass-market deployment and economics. This system uses preventive
techniques to help humans avoid emergency responses. It leverages a set
of surround cameras and harnesses the RSS framework to provide
preventive micro-interventions in accordance with principles of cautious
driving. It further benefits from lean, crowd-sourced foresight of
upcoming negotiation points and insights to dynamic road-usage patterns
and road-network safety vulnerabilities.
This is a very different approach to the current Vision Zero tactics
that focus on “road diets” being adopted by cities all over the world.
This movement has chosen to deepen the traffic rules with static and
pre-set rules like speed limits, speed bumps and physical barriers.
These road restrictions are making traffic rules more invasive, and
society is paying a high price in efficiency with questionable
Digitizing the social contract will help make our roads safer, with huge
upside potential for traffic flow. With proper regulatory endorsement,
these digitized principles of cautious driving may ultimately become a
formal, enforceable and binding contract, thereby mitigating the
weaknesses in the informal social contract today.
The RSS framework is the digital solution for the social contract that
tackles these inherent shortcomings. It also avoids the restrictions of
road diets. While RSS was originally envisioned for AVs, we can apply it
to ADAS solutions now with immediate impact. This is what I believe is
the next revolution in ADAS. It’s a very human concept come full circle.
Erez Dagan is the executive vice president for Products and Strategy
at Mobileye and a vice president at Intel Corporation.
Intel (NASDAQ: INTC), a leader in the semiconductor industry, is shaping
the data-centric future with computing and communications technology
that is the foundation of the world’s innovations. The company’s
engineering expertise is helping address the world’s greatest challenges
as well as helping secure, power and connect billions of devices and the
infrastructure of the smart, connected world – from the cloud to the
network to the edge and everything in between. Find more information
about Intel at newsroom.intel.com
Intel and the Intel logo are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the
United States and other countries.